Jerusalem Criticizes Berlin’s Jewish Museum for ‘Anti-Israel Activity’


BERLIN — This metropolis’s Jewish Museum prides itself on stirring issues up. In current exhibitions exploring Jewish stereotypes and attitudes to circumcision, the museum pushed guests to query what it means to be Jewish in Germany, and the world.

Its newest present, “Welcome to Jerusalem” additionally acquired folks speaking. And it appeared to attract criticism from an unlikely supply: the best ranges of the Israeli authorities.

The exhibition, which presents Jerusalem’s position as a crossroads of the world’s three monotheistic religions, is singled out in a letter that surfaced this month, with the title, “German Funding of Organizations Intervening in Israeli Domestic Affairs or Promoting anti-Israel Activity.”

The seven-page paper, which was first reported by the every day newspaper Die Tageszeitung, is unsigned and provides no indication of who wrote it, or who was the meant recipient. But Israeli officers, whereas not proudly owning as much as having written it, say they agree with its message: that the German authorities ought to halt any monetary assist to organizations or establishments the Israeli authorities views as undermining the Jewish state and siding with the Palestinians.

The letter singled out a number of organizations that it stated supported the worldwide motion to boycott, divest from and place sanctions on Israel, often called B.D.S., in addition to different actions described as “anti-Israel.” The most distinguished was the Jewish Museum, which the letter stated “often hosts events and discussions with prominent B.D.S. promoters.” It additionally stated its present exhibition about Jerusalem “reflected mainly the Muslim-Palestinian narrative.”

Although the holy sites of all three religions are represented, Schick’s masterpiece dwarfs the other two models, and this was interpreted by some Jewish bloggers and critics as giving an impression of Muslim dominance.

The wrangling over the Jewish Museum comes amid a broader campaign by the conservative government of Israel’s prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, to combat forces it deems hostile and accuses of defaming, delegitimizing or otherwise harming Israel.

Ms. Grütters rejected any suggestion that the Jewish Museum had offered a platform to “enemies of Israel, or fundamentalist, anti-democratic groups,” the spokeswoman added.

Israel maintains that, with the show in Berlin, and tours, lectures and events to accompany it, the museum has overstepped “the boundaries of the definition of its activities,” Emmanuel Nahshon, a spokesman for Israel’s foreign ministry, said. “The purpose and the reason of existence of the Jewish Museum is to preserve and show Jewish life in Germany throughout the centuries, and not to deal with the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and certainly not to take sides.”

Peter Schäfer, the museum’s director, said he realized that with such a fiercely debated topic, the show would not be able to please everyone. “Our exhibition does not aim to offer solutions. Instead, we hope it will generate an understanding of Jerusalem’s special situation and help visitors to form their own opinions,” Mr. Schäfer said when “Welcome to Jerusalem” opened.

In an interview on Thursday, he rejected the charge that the museum was offering anyone aligned with the pro-Palestinian sanctions movement a platform. “We do not offer a forum for activists of any political orientation, which goes in particular for supporters or activists of the B.D.S. campaign,” Mr. Schäfer said.

But one speaker who drew attention in 2012 was Judith Butler, one of the most influential feminist scholars and an early supporter of the B.D.S. movement, who took part in a panel discussion at the museum. Mr. Schäfer was not the director of the museum at the time.

Mr. Schäfer refused to comment on reports in the German media that the museum’s decision in July to relocate a lecture by Sa’ed Atshan, a Palestinian-born professor, had been in response to pressure from Israel’s embassy in Berlin, which says Mr. Atshan supports a boycott. Mr. Atshan declined to be interviewed.

His lecture on L.G.B.T. life in Jerusalem, part of the program accompanying the exhibition, was held elsewhere in Berlin, but the museum was sharply criticized for the last-minute change of venue. It said the lecture was moved because of “technical problems.”

The paper also singled out the Berlin Film Festival, known as the Berlinale, as an organization that “frequently hosts B.D.S. activities,” but did not provide any examples.

Dieter Kosslick, the festival’s director, said that his office had not received the letter. Nor had the German government ever put conditions on the €8.2 million, or about $9.2 million, in annual support that it provides for the festival, he said.

“The founding idea of the Berlin Film Festival was to contribute to international understanding by presenting the different perspectives of artists from around the world,” Mr. Kosslick said. “These viewpoints may be controversial, but our role is to support freedom of the arts within the bounds of the democratic principles as enshrined in the German constitution.”

There has been some pushback in Israel, too. Tamar Zandberg, leader of the left-wing Meretz party, which sits in the opposition, decried what she called Mr. Netanyahu’s “obsession” with pursuing and censoring ideological opponents all the way to the Jewish Museum in Berlin.

“Israel was founded, among other things, to protect the Jews against persecution,” she said. “Now the Israeli government is coming out against a place and an exhibit most identified with the history of that persecution.”

She added, “The Israeli government — not the B.D.S. supporters and not the neo-Nazi organizations — is the one calling for a boycott of an important Jewish institution.”



Source link Nytimes.com

Get more stuff like this

Subscribe to our mailing list and get interesting stuff and updates to your email inbox.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get more stuff like this
in your inbox

Subscribe to our mailing list and get interesting stuff and updates to your email inbox.