Exclusive: SEC scrutinizes fairness of stock exchange pricing

NEW YORK (Reuters) – The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission is investigating whether or not the multi-tiered pricing system utilized by stock exchanges favors massive brokers on the expense of small ones, in keeping with an individual acquainted with the matter.

FILE PHOTO: Jay Clayton, Chairman of the Securities and Exchange Commission, speaks throughout an interview with CNBC on the Sandler O’Neill + Partners Global Exchange and Brokerage Conference in New York, U.S., June 6, 2018. REUTERS/Brendan McDermid

Under the present system, Wall Street banks and different large merchants get hefty rebates based mostly on how a lot enterprise they funnel to exchanges. The consequence of this complicated and sometimes opaque system is that huge customers can find yourself buying and selling free of charge, and even receives a commission to commerce, whereas small brokers pay substantial charges.

Most exchange operators, together with New York Stock Exchange-owner Intercontinental Exchange Inc, Nasdaq Inc and Cboe Global Markets, have embraced the system in a minimum of some of their exchanges to assist increase volumes and fatten their backside strains.

While the SEC has not launched a proper civil investigation, it’s looking for info from the exchanges on the pricing system. If the SEC have been to find out that the tiered construction is unfair, exchanges might be pressured to simplify their pricing fashions, doubtlessly costing them thousands and thousands of in charges.

SEC spokeswoman Judith Burns declined to remark. NYSE and Nasdaq declined to touch upon the SEC probe into multi-tiered pricing.

Cboe mentioned it provides differing kinds of pricing tiers catering to all of its shoppers and that the tiers are the consequence of years of intense competitors amongst exchanges.

“At this point, we do not have plans to change our pricing schedules,” mentioned Bryan Harkins, who co-heads Cboe’s markets division.

More typically, exchanges say that fierce competitors within the trade has resulted in tighter bid-ask spreads that profit all traders.

The regulatory scrutiny is an element of a broader effort by the SEC below Chairman Jay Clayton to enhance transparency round exchange pricing and guarantee it’s honest and equitable as required below the Exchange Act.

“The SEC has thrown the gauntlet down,” mentioned Chester Spatt, a finance professor at Carnegie Mellon University and a former chief economist at SEC. Tiered pricing will doubtless emerge as a central problem within the debate, mentioned Spatt, who has a working paper on the subject.

The regulator has additionally ordered exchanges to justify latest payment hikes for market information, and has mandated a pilot program to check banning rebate funds that exchanges make to brokers for liquidity-adding stock orders.

ICE, Nasdaq and Cboe have filed lawsuits or appeals difficult the SEC’s authority on these two mandates.

Tackling U.S. exchanges is one of the few areas the place Republicans and Democrats agree. Republicans imagine the present guidelines are anti-competitive, whereas Democrats fear current exchange buildings and incentives may damage small and huge traders.

(For graphic evaluating quantity of small brokers to mid- and large-sized brokers, see: tmsnrt.rs/2VKfgCw)


Tensions between Wall Street and the exchanges, which have been as soon as member-owned, not-for-profit utilities, have risen over the previous decade and a half because the bourses have develop into public firms.

Some brokers say the exchanges have used their important place available in the market to maximise earnings, usually to the detriment of smaller brokers.

Joe Wald, chief government of brokerage Clearpool Group, mentioned tiered pricing makes it more durable for smaller brokers to compete for buyer orders towards larger corporations, which get vital reductions on buying and selling prices.

“It discriminates against smaller broker dealers who end up almost perversely subsidizing the cost of the whole exchange relationship for the largest firms,” he mentioned.

Clearpool executes greater than 2 p.c of U.S. stock trades on a mean day, however comes nowhere close to hitting the higher-volume exchange tiers, which permit the largest brokers to reap rebates almost 60 p.c greater than people who qualify for base charges, Wald mentioned.

When factoring in rebate funds from the exchanges, 5 of the highest 10 clients at each Nasdaq and Cboe by quantity really obtain checks from the exchanges on the finish of the month, internet of charges, in accordance latest feedback by a Cboe government and a Nasdaq report.


The present payment schedule was authorised by the SEC, and exchange pricing lists are publicly accessible. But they are often dozens of pages lengthy and it’s unattainable to know which brokers qualify for which tiers.

An evaluation by RBC Capital Markets in October discovered a minimum of 1,023 “pricing paths” throughout exchanges, made up of three,762 variables, that means that there are dozens of doable internet costs for execution.

“These 3,762 variables strongly suggest that exchange prices are tailored and offered on a bespoke basis,” the report mentioned.

Exchanges have credited pricing tiers for serving to increase revenues. Bats, an exchange operator that has since been bought to Cboe, mentioned the introduction of tiered pricing for its markets in July 2011 helped improve revenues by $14.6 million over the remaining of that 12 months.

Large brokers, which embrace funding banks and high-frequency buying and selling corporations, may also revenue from tiered pricing by providing smaller brokers that funnel their orders via them a portion of their steeper reductions, whereas retaining the rest.

Cboe’s Harkins mentioned that this “sponsored access” permits smaller corporations to share within the financial savings with huge brokers.

Reporting by John McCrank; Editing by Neal Templin and Meredith Mazzilli

Our Standards:The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.

Source link reuters.com

Get more stuff like this

Subscribe to our mailing list and get interesting stuff and updates to your email inbox.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get more stuff like this
in your inbox

Subscribe to our mailing list and get interesting stuff and updates to your email inbox.